I Need YOUR Opinion!!

So here's the deal: Brian and I need to buy a new car. We are buying used, and are looking for a sedan of some sort. We want something that will last a while..gets great gas mileage, is worth its cost, will NOT need to be worked on once a month (how annoying is that?), is safe to lug our babygirl around in, and OF COURSE, is easy on the eyes!! Any suggestions?

Right now I'm leaning toward this one...